Yay, love Sorels! They're what got our little childhood feet through the horrific Alberta winters (well the boots, not the slippers). I'd go with #1. They've got that cute pattern on the side.
Thanks for your input, Ali! I like #1 too! Glad to hear Sorel's have a good reputation in your book!
I'm biased toward blue, but I think the first looks more like "Christy" slippers. :)
Christen :) that is exactly what I was going to say!
Christy - you are a true Howe. I thought Lombards kept their socks for a long time, but over our history together I've seen that Howes definitely have given us a run for our money..